Editorial illustration for Musk offers to give damages to OpenAI nonprofit as judge rejects punitive claim
Musk Offers Damages to OpenAI in Surprising Legal Twist
Musk offers to give damages to OpenAI nonprofit as judge rejects punitive claim
Elon Musk now says any damages he wins from his lawsuit against OpenAI should go to the nonprofit's original mission, not to him. The shift comes after U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley rejected his bid for punitive damages on April 4. She also dismissed the financial premise of his case, which argued that his $38 million in early donations led to $134 billion in wrongful gains for OpenAI and Microsoft.
A week prior to Musk's filing, the judge denied Musk's request for punitive damages. She also agreed with defendants that Musk's expert--who calculated that OpenAI and Microsoft's wrongful gains from Musk's early donation of $38 million could near $134 billion--didn't calculate remedies in a way that supported Musk's arguments for disgorgement. In other words, Musk failed to argue that he should get to pocket those damages.
Musk's legal theories fizzled out It seems clear from Gonzalez Rogers' order that Musk realized he needed to change his damages claims to keep the lawsuit alive. She also denied his request to instruct the jury about his theory that his damages "accrued every time Defendants used the fruits of Musk's contributions to pursue purposes other than the charitable purposes for which those contributions were given."
The amended complaint, filed in a San Francisco federal court, reframes the suit. Musk no longer seeks personal profit. Instead, he asks the court to direct any potential award to an independent trust that would support OpenAI's founding goal of developing artificial intelligence for public benefit. Legal experts say the move tries to salvage a breach of contract claim by focusing on whether a donor can legally enforce the charitable purpose of a gift.
Related Reading
Browse all OpenAI news →
Business & Startups Nordic pilot adds Gemini for Education, NotebookLM to boost AI literacy
Business & Startups Kling launches Video O1, all-in-one model with MVL bridge using transformer
Business & Startups DeepSeek Seeks More Capital Weeks After USD 7B Funding Round
Related Topic OpenAI researcher quits, citing distrust over ad‑driven engagement metrics
LLMs & Generative AI
Related Topic OpenAI launches GPT-Image 1.5 with precise editing for enterprise visuals
LLMs & Generative AI
From Archives Meta reenters AI race with Muse Spark, Llama successor after billions spent
From Archives Anthropic restricts access to Mythos AI after data leak of model details
From Archives OpenAI CEO Altman says profit not expected until 2029, per 2024 reports
From Archives OpenAI insiders distrust Sam Altman as vows policies while AI outperforms humans
Open Source
Common Questions Answered
What damages did Elon Musk offer to provide to OpenAI's nonprofit arm?
Musk filed a new legal pleading promising that any potential award he might win would be directed to OpenAI's nonprofit organization. This move comes after previous legal setbacks in his lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, effectively removing any personal financial gain from the case.
Why did the judge reject Musk's request for punitive damages?
The judge determined that Musk's damages expert failed to calculate remedies in a legally acceptable manner that would support his arguments for disgorgement. Specifically, the court sided with OpenAI and Microsoft, finding that the expert's projected $134 billion in wrongful gains did not meet the legal standard for damages.
What was the original context of Musk's lawsuit against OpenAI?
The lawsuit stems from Musk's original $38 million donation to OpenAI and subsequent allegations of the company deviating from its original nonprofit mission. By filing this amended pleading, Musk aims to redirect any potential damages to OpenAI's charitable nonprofit arm, potentially neutralizing claims that the lawsuit is merely harassment.
Further Reading
- Musk v. Altman: The $134 Billion OpenAI Trial Explained — Lets Data Science
- Judge Questions Musk's $134bn Damages Claim in OpenAI Lawsuit — Distilled Post
- Papers with Code - Latest NLP Research — Papers with Code
- Hugging Face Daily Papers — Hugging Face
- ArXiv CS.CL (Computation and Language) — ArXiv
